On October 25th, the Board of the Henry Dunant Prize Foundation is pleased to award the Henry Dunant Prize — Research for the year 2024 to Ritika Sharma.
Biography
Summary of LL.M. Paper
The first section lays down the introduction and scope of the research and then the paper presents two feminist schools of thought. The first school asserts that IHL is adequate but lacks enforcement, while the revisionist school argues that IHL provisions are inadequate and does not take into account the unique experiences of women. Sexual violence is also absent from the category of “grave breach”. To fill these gaps, the paper proposes a solution of invoking the “dictates of the public conscience”.
The next section discusses the meaning and relevance of the “dictates of the public conscience”. Martens Clause was introduced in 1899 to address gaps by invoking “principles of humanity” and the “dictates of the public conscience.” While initially meant to supplement incomplete treaties, the clause remains significant in IHL as seen in the 1949 Geneva Conventions and Additional Protocols. Identified from authoritative acts, resolutions and practices, the paper highlights that the “dictates of the public conscience” can also be harnessed from religion. This section submits that the potential of “dictates of the public conscience” to enhance protection and alleviate the suffering of women during CoH must not be overlooked.
In the following section, the paper explores how Hinduism and Buddhism provide ethical frameworks that protect women from sexual violence. It discusses the Hindu principles of dharma, as seen in epics like the Mahabharata and Ramayana, and the Buddhist precepts against sexual misconduct. Both religions, through their teachings, promote the protection of women.
The paper then presents a reality check looking into the Sri Lankan civil war, the Myanmar conflict and the conduct of Hindu nationalists in India to study whether the principles and ideals discussed in the previous section have been followed in practice. In Sri Lanka, despite its Buddhist majority, government forces systematically used sexual violence against Tamil women, violating Buddhist precepts against sexual misconduct. The Sri Lankan conflict also highlighted the additional vulnerabilities faced by minority women, with cases of coerced religious conversions and a lack of support from authorities. In Myanmar, the military’s violent campaign against the Rohingya people saw the widespread use of sexual violence as a weapon of ethnic cleansing. Despite Buddhist teachings on non-violence and compassion, radical monks incited violence by portraying Rohingya men as predators. Sexual violence was systematically used to terrorize the Rohingya, destroy their community, and assert ethnic and religious dominance. Similarly, in various parts of India, Hindu nationalists engaged in conduct that contradicted Hindu ethics of prohibiting rape and sexual violence against women. This section highlights how the involvement of religious leaders, both in inciting and opposing violence, presents the complex role religion plays in such conflicts.
The paper concludes by emphasizing that religion plays a crucial role in armed conflicts, and understanding the core values of communities is essential to addressing the challenges of armed conflicts. Initiatives like the ICRC’s work with religious circles and the United Nations’ Faith for Rights framework illustrate how religious teachings can enhance humanitarian efforts. Thus, the “dictates of the public conscience” harnessed from religions have the potential to address the issue of sexual violence against women during the conduct of hostilities.
More information about Ritika Sharma
Additionally, on 5 November 2024, I will be (virtually) presenting my LL.M Paper at the “Faith for Rights commUNity of Practices: Fifth Annual Meeting 2024” to be held in Palais Wilson, Geneva.
In the future, I aim to continue working for women’s rights in the humanitarian sector and dedicate my career to working on these critical issues within the South Asian context.
Laudatio
The Henry Dunant Research Prize is awarded by the Board of the Henry Dunant Prize Foundation to individuals or organizations who have done outstanding work in furthering, promoting and renewing the ideas and commitments of Henry Dunant.
For more than 10 years, the Dunant Prize Foundation Board has awarded the prize each year to the dissertation of one of the Geneva Academy students that best reflects the ideals, communication skills and activism of Henry Dunant. This year, three dissertations representing Henry Dunant’s values were nominated for the prize:
- Ms. Elien Desmet’s dissertation examines the effectiveness of sanctions as a means of ensuring compliance with international humanitarian law.
- The second dissertation, by Ms. Ritika Sharma, deals with the religious foundations of Hinduism and Buddhism in the fight against sexual violence against women during hostilities.
- The third, by Ms Clémence Wondon, looks at the dignity of victims and respect for their posthumous rights.
The Henry Dunant Prize Foundation Board wishes to congratulate the nominees – three women – on the excellence of their work. We would also like to thank the Geneva Academy for the fruitful collaboration.
The Prize Jury, gathering members of the Geneva Academy, the ICRC and the Henry Dunant Prize Foundation, read the three submitted works with great interest. Once again, the choice proved difficult. While the three dissertations fall within the scope of the issues dear to Henry Dunant, one in particular caught the attention of both the jury at its meeting on 9 October and the members of the Foundation.
Ms Ritika Sharma’s work has thus been selected to receive the Prix Henry Dunant recherche 2024 in recognition of the values conveyed in her research.
Firstly, because of Ms. Sharma’ interest in the victims of persecution, and more particularly women, two important themes in Henry Dunant’s struggles: indeed, he envisaged creating a Green Cross to protect women and children.
Secondly, for the attention paid by Ms. Sharma’s work to the values of non-Western civilizations through the analysis of the religious foundations for the protection of women within Hinduism and Buddhism. Henry Dunant also used to question the ‘superiority of the Christian West’ without any hesitation and railed against the destruction of non-European civilizations.
Thirdly, Ms. Sharma’s ability to communicate and the deep compassion that runs through her thesis convinced the members of the jury. Henry Dunant himself showed a deep sensitivity to all human suffering and did not hesitate to seek support from all quarters.
These values, which lie at the very heart of Henry Dunant’s commitment, are particularly present in the work of Ms. Sharma.
The Jury, the Geneva Academy and the Henry Dunant Prize Foundation Board are hence delighted to award her the 2024 Henry Dunant Research Prize.
They wish to congratulate her on her work and look forward to following her future career.
Vidéos
Voici 3 vidéos de la remise du Prix, le 25 octobre 2024.
Roger Durand presents the Prix Henry Dunant (in French)
Etienne Kuster awards the Prix Henry Dunant – Recherche 2024 to Ritika Sharma
Ritika Sharma accepts the Prix Henry Dunant at the 2024 Graduation Ceremony
Links